The publication that built its name on demanding transparency is refusing to answer the questions it once asked of others.
The Canary built its entire reputation on one idea: that power should be held to account, that transparency is non-negotiable, and that people deserve to know who owns and controls the media they trust. The question is whether The Canary applies those standards to itself.
From Workers' Co-op to Private Ownership. Did Anyone Tell the Readers?
For those of us who'd spent years watching the media owned by billionaires ignore or distort our politics, a workers' co-operative felt like proof that something different was possible. An independent media that answered to no one with deep pockets.
On 3 October 2022, the Canary announced that staff had "overthrown" the outlet's previous directors and relaunched as a workers' co-operative. Their own announcement declared: "We are owned and controlled by and for our members. Everyone who works at the Canary is a member of the co-op. We're democratic, and all our members have an equal say in how we're run."
That was the promise. Many of The Canary's readers believed it, celebrated it, and supported it with subscriptions. Many still do.
What we were not told is that this structure has since been abandoned.
Company records show that a new major shareholder was brought into The Canary's private parent company in August 2025, while The Canary was still publicly branding itself as a workers' co-operative. Two months later, in October 2025, the workers' co-operative legal entity was officially dissolved. The horizontal dream was over, and the media outlet returned to a conventional private structure.
Steve Topple, its Chief Executive Officer and most prominent journalist, now holds approximately 66.7% of the shares. Cecil Robert Hetherington is the only other listed director and holds a significant stake through his company Ulidia Investments Ltd.
There appears to have been no public communication to readers about the co-operative being dissolved or the new private investor. And at the time of writing this, The Canary's YouTube channel still carries the description "We are now the Canary Workers' Co-op.” This raises legitimate questions about whether readers whose trust and subscriptions sustain this publication are being given an accurate picture of who now owns it.
Who Is Cecil Hetherington?
Cecil Robert Hetherington is a businessman from Craigavon in Northern Ireland with a background in property investment, automotive marketplaces and digital ventures. He founded Used Cars NI and chairs PropertyPal, the dominant property listings platform in Northern Ireland. He had no known history of involvement in socialist politics, left media or journalism prior to 2025.
According to sources familiar with the transaction, he reportedly paid around £300,000 to acquire stakes in both The Canary and Skwawkbox, with the two deals concluded together. Hetherington confirmed to the trade publication A Media Operator that he approached The Canary and initiated the deal. The Canary declined to confirm the financial terms.
Hetherington's media interests stretch well beyond the independent left. By November 2025, just weeks after joining the boards of both The Canary and Declassified, he had built a stake of over 5% in Reach plc, the company that owns the Daily Mirror, Daily Express and dozens of regional titles, crossing three Stock Exchange reporting thresholds in the space of three weeks. He is now one of Reach's most significant individual shareholders. The people who subscribed to what they thought was a workers' co-op are now, in part, funding someone who has a major stake in the mainstream press.
The Canary Did Not Look Out of Window
"If someone says it's raining and another person says it's dry, it's not your job to quote them both. Your job is to look out the fucking window and find out which is true."
Journalism 101, via Sally Claire
In November 2025, The Canary published what it called an exclusive, based on a cache of documents leaked to them by one side in the Your Party dispute. The piece was not a neutral account of events. It was a defence of Andrew Feinstein, Jamie Driscoll and Beth Winter, and a direct attack on Jeremy Corbyn's team and the Independent Alliance MPs.
⬇️
https://x.com/thecanaryuk/status/1983889372677042474?s=46&t=kIgRREfwfQrwlmZTA1voug
The Canary's framing was one-sided: MOU Operations and its directors were victims of a smear campaign, and Your Party had blocked a straightforward data and funds handover. Your Party's public statements were, in The Canary's own words, "verifiably untrue."
The Canary stated it had "reviewed the documents" and could "verify that MOU Operations had no involvement whatsoever" in the portal launch, and that the directors had "contacted Corbyn and reiterated that they had had no involvement in the launch triggered by Sultana."
There are a number of things The Canary chose not to mention:
• Both Feinstein and Driscoll had promoted the unauthorised portal on their own social media when it launched on 18 September 2025. The privacy document published on the portal itself named MOU Operations Ltd as data controller, which is evidence of active backend configuration by MOU Operations Ltd or someone acting with their authority. This information was in the public domain. The Canary did not look out the window.
• The Information Commissioner's Office was investigating the unauthorised access and use of data connected to the portal launch, and Your Party was acting on legal advice that they could not accept the data and funds until those investigations were concluded. Your Party had made this known.
• Feinstein sat on the board of Declassified Media, where The Canary's new investor Cecil Hetherington had just taken a seat.
On the day of publication, The Canary sent Your Party an email at 13:03 seeking a response, and giving a 16:00 deadline. Canary’s article went live shortly after the email was sent - almost three hours before the deadline - and before any response. When Your Party provided a detailed rebuttal, The Canary updated their article to include just a single line of it. The rest was ignored.
Setting a 16:00 deadline and publishing before the deadline had passed raises questions about whether a response was ever meaningfully sought.
The Canary posted a promotional tweet with the article naming Feinstein, Driscoll and Winter by their Twitter handles and told readers that they were the subjects of a “smear campaign.”
This reads less like journalism covering a dispute and more like a publication taking a position in support of named individuals, while the investor on its board sits on the board of another media outlet where one of those individuals is a director.
The Story Was Already Written
What follows was first highlighted by twitter account @EL4C in screenshots and commentary posted on 1 March 2026.
⬇️
https://x.com/el4jc/status/2028214987605299377?s=46&t=kIgRREfwfQrwlmZTA1voug
These screenshots appear to show Canary journalist Maddison Wheeldon (@MaddisonW92) operating inside a Grassroots Left WhatsApp group. On 17 February 2026, Wheeldon posted in the group: “Will cover it for Canary on Monday” - confirming she was acting in her professional capacity as a Canary journalist, not as a private individual.
Her quote request didn't ask what members thought. It invited them to confirm a pre-written conclusion: the "very clear absence of a toxic whip-style system in the grassroots left" and "the reality it truly is a new type of politics being born."
The conclusion was already written. She was crowd-sourcing the evidence to fit it.
When one group member pointed out there would in fact be a whip to keep people in line with the platform, Wheeldon clarified she was contrasting grassroots culture with a "Zarah enforced whip… like we see on JC team." The piece was not an investigation, it was a brief with a byline.
The same exchange shows Wheeldon saying she received a direct briefing from Craig Lloyd, Zarah Sultana MPs husband. At 16:43 on the same day, she wrote: “Just heard from Craig, Zara’s husband, they’re looking for candidates”. She relayed this to the group without any indication she would seek a response from Your Party or the Independent Alliance.
It’s apparent that this WhatsApp chat was being used for quotes to back up a conclusion that had already been written. That isn’t independent journalism. It’s building a story backwards.

The Questions Mr Topple Won't Answer
On 7 October 2025, I put a series of questions to Steve Topple publicly in a post on Twitter addressed directly to him and The Canary's account.
⬇️
https://x.com/naj562/status/1975601135084769405?s=46&t=kIgRREfwfQrwlmZTA1voug
• What is the exact shareholding held by Ulidia Investments Ltd?
• How much was invested?
• Does the new investor have any formal or informal influence over editorial or staffing decisions?
• Why did the board accept investment from someone without a socialist or journalistic track record?
• Does the original worker co-operative model remain intact?
• Is there still a written editorial charter guaranteeing independence from shareholders and directors?
• Who now appoints or dismisses editors and signs off commissioning budgets?
• Who holds final editorial sign-off for politically sensitive pieces?
Raising these questions wasn’t comfortable, but the people who built The Canary through their subscriptions, sharing posts and their belief in something better, deserve the truth about who now owns the media outlet they supported.
Neither Steve Topple nor The Canary responded at the time, and their silence spoke volumes.
Is the Answer in the Boardroom?
I haven’t found any record of Hetherington’s investment being reported in The Canary. It was covered by A Media Operator, a trade publication that most Canary readers will never have come across. In it, Topple confirmed that Hetherington approached him and initiated the deal, and said there were no links with other companies connected to him. That was accurate at the time he said it. However, six weeks later, on 22 September 2025, Hetherington was appointed to the board of Declassified Media Ltd, and now sits on the boards of two left media outlets at the same time. I’ve seen no indication that The Canary told its readers this, or that Andrew Feinstein was already on that board.
The earlier connection between Hetherington and Feinstein may not have been widely known at the time. Hetherington had contributed to an organisation called OCISA, which supported Feinstein’s campaign against Keir Starmer in the 2024 general election. That campaign established Feinstein as a highly visible face of left opposition to the Labour leadership.
What hasn’t been addressed is whether it is a coincidence or something else, that someone with no documented background in left politics holds a position at a publication whose editorial direction has shifted towards a person he has financially supported and now sits on a board with.
So let's set out what we know.
A businessman from Northman Ireland with no known socialist background backs Feinstein’s election campaign in 2024. The following year he buys into The Canary in August, and joins the Declassified board in September - the same media outlet Feinstein joined that February. In the months that follow, The Canary shifts towards Feinstein and Zarah Sultana MP against Jeremy Corbyn and the Independent Alliance MPs. The Canary publishes a one-sided piece based on documents from Feinstein’s allies, defends him by name in its promotional tweet, and frames legitimate governance questions as a smear campaign.
Individually, each of these developments may be coincidental. Taken together, they raise legitimate questions about editorial independence that have not been addressed publicly. They are also the kind of coincidences that The Canary, in the past, would have pursued relentlessly.
The Same Errors, the Same Direction, the Same Week
The Canary is not alone in this.
Anyone following the Your Party controversy will have noticed that multiple publications on the independent left reported it in strikingly similar terms. Same claims, same framing, same errors, often in the same week.
Novara Media, Turn Left and others amplified the claim that the four male Muslim Independent Alliance MPs were "single issue" on Gaza and not genuinely socialist. That claim is directly contradicted by their parliamentary voting record: consistent votes for higher windfall taxes, stronger tenants' rights, workers' rights protections, public energy investment, climate regulation and more. The claim was wrong and easily verifiable, yet it was stated with confidence across multiple platforms in the same week.
⬇️
https://x.com/naj562/status/1991070095443976244?s=46&t=kIgRREfwfQrwlmZTA1voug
When these errors were pointed out, with evidence and the public record, the response was silence - or deflection.
This is not how mistakes look. Mistakes get corrected. This is what building a narrative looks like.
Their Own Words
The Canary recently published the following about itself:
“At The Canary, we have faced relentless abuse and criticism for insisting on transparency and holding those in power to account. Yet we have refused to back down, because we believe all power deserves scrutiny. Not just the power of those we oppose. After all, power corrupts, and humans are fallible.”
All power deserves scrutiny. The Canary said it. So here are the questions, one more time, in exactly that spirit:
• Why was the workers' co-operative dissolved without any announcement to the readership that built it? And why does The Canary's YouTube channel still describe itself as a workers' co-op?
• Who owns The Canary now, on what terms, and what editorial safeguards are in place?
• Why were serious allegations published before The Canary's own stated response deadline had passed?
• Why did a journalist working for The Canary operate inside a partisan political group, take briefings from a politician's husband, and publish the result as independent journalism?
• Why have repeated, specific, good-faith governance questions received no response from the majority shareholder and CEO?
Response From The Canary
Before this piece was published, I emailed Steve Topple and The Canary with a detailed right of reply with 24 hours to respond. For context that is eight times longer than they gave Your Party.
Steve Topple’s response was: “Thanks for this, but we won’t be responding to anything contained within your request.”
No specific claim was addressed. No correction was offered. No alternative account was provided. However, he did sign off as Director and CEO of Canary Media Ltd. Not a workers’ co-operative - a private company. That much, at least, he has now confirmed.
The Canary's readers deserve answers. They built this publication with their subscriptions and their trust. The least it owes them is the transparency it demands of everyone else.
This is the first in a series examining transparency and editorial independence in the UK's independent left media. Further investigation is ongoing.
With particular thanks to Chelley Ryan, researcher, editor, and fellow traveller in asking the uncomfortable questions.












Thanks for this Nicola - and Chelley.
I was not aware of any of this but I do know that during the course of last year I was getting frustrated at The Canary and Skawkbox because I sensed a clear shift in tone and angle by them. It began to resemble mainstream media clickbait, divide and conquer style and model and I'd made a couple of comments to that affect. Eventually I ended my subscription that I'd made since the Kerry-Ann Mendoza founding days
What a shame. Used to love the Canary, under Kerry-Anne